SkeptVet renews debate over alternative medicine and science
A new SkeptVet commentary is arguing that so-called complementary and alternative veterinary medicine isn’t a separate, compatible lane alongside science-based care, but a category defined largely by weaker evidentiary standards and, in some cases, claims that conflict with established biology and physiology. In the post, “Is Alternative Medicine Compatible with Science?”, veterinarian and longtime evidence-based medicine advocate Brennen McKenzie revisits familiar flashpoints including homeopathy, chiropractic, herbal remedies, laser therapy, and acupuncture, and contends that therapies shown to work should simply be considered medicine, while those lacking good evidence shouldn’t be insulated by “holistic” or “integrative” branding. That argument lands amid ongoing professional debate over how veterinary medicine should handle complementary modalities, including a 2025 letter from the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medical Association opposing recognition of veterinary acupuncture as an AVMA specialty, saying the evidence base remains insufficient. (skeptvet.com)
Why it matters: For veterinary professionals, this is less a philosophical debate than a practice standards issue. Major veterinary bodies that have addressed complementary medicine generally emphasize that such therapies shouldn’t replace conventional care, shouldn’t delay effective treatment, and should be discussed with pet parents in the context of evidence, safety, qualifications, and possible interactions. Reviews of complementary and alternative veterinary medicine also note that client interest is real and rising, which means clinicians need enough familiarity with these modalities to counsel pet parents clearly, even when the evidence is limited or mixed. (bva.co.uk)
What to watch: Expect continued pressure on the profession to define where “integrative” care ends and unsupported claims begin, especially around acupuncture, herbal products, education, and specialty recognition. (skeptvet.com)